Tuesday, March 20, 2012

Second Blog Post-Book Reviews

Reader Review
     Mary Shine Thompson wrote a very detailed book review. She goes very in depth with her words. She compares and contrasts Room with other previous abduction and murder cases; such as Jaycee Lee Duggard and Josef Fritzel. Emma Donoghue claims that Room is completely fiction, but her story is very similiar to many other abduction cases. She also compares Room to The Boy in the Striped Pajamas. I'm not so sure that these two stories really go together, because The Boy in the Striped Pajamas was about a boy getting trapped in an extermination camp on accident because he was trying to save his friend. The Holocaust and being trapped in a garden shed by a rapist are sort of two different things, but at the same time I can see why she made that comparison.
     I like the fact that she relates herself to the story in her book review. An example of this would be when she says that, "A day spent with his uncle and cousin would be hilarious were it not for the chaos and panic he creates everywhere." 

Shine Thompson, Mary. "Review: Room by Emma Donoghue." Rev. of Room. Independent I.e. Irish Independent, 24 July 2010. Web. 20 Mar. 2012. <http://www.independent.ie/entertainment/books/review-room-by-emma-donoghue-2271033.html>.

Professional Review
      This book review was a very short but to the point review. It goes to explain that all the little activities that I found kind of wierd in the begginning of the book, were all activities that were helping Jack train for him and Ma's escape. These activities included screaming at night, flickering the light on and off and hiding in the wardrobe, etc. This review wasnt quite as in-depth as the first one, and it didn't have many personal opinions and extra facts about the book like the first review did. I do think that if this was published onto the back of the book, Room, that it would make the potential reader want to read it. The last few sentences that talk about the sun, Jack uses 'God's face' as an analogy to the sun; this adds an emotional effect to the book review.

"Room." The New Yorker 11 Oct. 2010: 104. General Reference Center GOLD. Web. 20 Mar. 2012.

Professional Review 
     This was my favorite book review out of all of them. I believe all of them were great and all were very in depth, but this one definately had a catch to it, and made me want to keep reading, I was not bored. I love the way that the author describes the intensity of Ma; trying to raise her child and find an escape, while also trying to overcome days of intense depression and anger. This book review, much like the reader review, gives  background information on the Fritzel case. It notes that Emma Donoghue was driving in her car and heard about the Fritzel case on the radio. She was shocked, but instantly her idea for Room came to her. 
     This review also has a better description of Jack's fear of the New world. He is terrified, and knows nothing. Everything is brand new to him, and has every emotion all at once; fear, sadness, excitement, etc. 


Bethune, Brian. "A room without a view: Emma Donoghue's new novel is claustrophobic, controversial and brilliant." Maclean's 13 Sept. 2010: 78. General Reference Center GOLD. Web. 20 Mar. 2012.

1 comment:

  1. I find it interesting that one of the professional reviews was your favorite. The experts really do know what they're doing!

    ReplyDelete